All Debt Relief Options Explained
Compare all 8 major debt relief strategies side-by-side. Find the best solution for your unique financial situation.
$15,000+
2-4 Years
87%
Not sure which option is best?
Get personalized recommendations in 2 minutes
Minimum Payments ("Brute Force")
Continue making minimum payments on all debts while slowly paying down balances.
15-30 years
Positive (if payments made on time)
$0 (highest total cost)
Pros
- Maintains good credit score
- No additional fees or programs needed
- Keeps all credit lines open
Cons
- Extremely slow progress (can take 20+ years)
- Highest total interest paid over time
- No reduction in monthly payment burden
Best For:
- • Small debt amounts (under $5,000)
- • Those with stable high income
Debt Consolidation Loan
Combine multiple debts into a single loan with one monthly payment, ideally at a lower interest rate.
3-7 years
Neutral to positive (small dip initially, then improves)
30-50% on interest
Pros
- Single monthly payment simplifies budgeting
- Often lower interest rate than credit cards
- Fixed payment amount and payoff date
Cons
- Requires good credit (typically 650+)
- May have origination fees (2-8% of loan)
- Doesn't reduce principal owed
Best For:
- • Good credit score (650+)
- • Multiple high-interest debts
Debt Relief/Settlement Program
Negotiate with creditors to pay less than you owe, typically through a debt relief company.
2-4 years
Very negative (100+ point drop, stays for 7 years)
20-40% after all fees
Pros
- Can reduce debt by 40-60% after fees
- Become debt-free in 2-4 years
- Single monthly program payment
Cons
- Severely damages credit (drops 100+ points)
- Creditors may sue during program
- Program fees are typically 20-25% of enrolled debt
Best For:
- • Significant unsecured debt ($10,000+)
- • Already behind on payments
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
Legal process that eliminates most unsecured debts completely in 3-6 months.
3-6 months
Severe (200+ point drop, on report for 10 years)
100% of eligible debt eliminated
Pros
- Eliminates most debts completely
- Fast process (3-6 months)
- Immediate protection from creditors
Cons
- Stays on credit report for 10 years
- May lose non-exempt assets
- Cannot discharge student loans (usually)
Best For:
- • Overwhelming debt with no ability to pay
- • Low income (pass means test)
Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
Court-supervised repayment plan lasting 3-5 years, allowing you to keep assets while catching up on debts.
3-5 years
Severe (150+ point drop, on report for 7 years)
Varies, often pay back 10-100% depending on income
Pros
- Keep all assets including home
- Stop foreclosure proceedings
- Reduce some debt balances
Cons
- Long process (3-5 years)
- Must have regular income
- Strict budget supervision
Best For:
- • Regular income above means test
- • Want to save home from foreclosure
Home Equity Loan/HELOC
Borrow against your home's equity to pay off high-interest debts with a lower-rate secured loan.
5-30 years
Neutral (small initial dip, then positive)
40-60% on interest vs credit cards
Pros
- Lower interest rates than credit cards
- Interest may be tax-deductible
- Fixed payment with HEL
Cons
- Puts home at risk
- Requires significant equity (20%+)
- Closing costs and fees
Best For:
- • Homeowners with 20%+ equity
- • Good credit score
401(k) Loan or Withdrawal
Borrow from or withdraw your retirement savings to pay off debts.
5 years max for loans
None (doesn't appear on credit)
Varies based on retirement impact
Pros
- No credit check required
- Lower interest than credit cards
- Interest paid to yourself
Cons
- Reduces retirement savings
- Penalties if can't repay
- Withdrawals taxed as income
Best For:
- • Substantial 401(k) balance
- • Stable job (loan due if leave)
Family/Friend Loan ("Rich Uncle")
Borrow from family or friends to pay off debts, typically at low or no interest.
Negotiable
None
100% of interest costs
Pros
- No or low interest
- Flexible repayment terms
- No credit check
Cons
- Can damage relationships
- No credit building
- Informal terms can cause issues
Best For:
- • Have willing family/friends
- • Can maintain clear boundaries
Quick Comparison Table
| Option | Time | Credit Impact | Savings | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15-30 years | Positive (if payments made on time) | $0 (highest total cost) | Small debt amounts (under $5,000) | |
| 3-7 years | Neutral to positive (small dip initially, then improves) | 30-50% on interest | Good credit score (650+) | |
| 2-4 years | Very negative (100+ point drop, stays for 7 years) | 20-40% after all fees | Significant unsecured debt ($10,000+) | |
| 3-6 months | Severe (200+ point drop, on report for 10 years) | 100% of eligible debt eliminated | Overwhelming debt with no ability to pay | |
| 3-5 years | Severe (150+ point drop, on report for 7 years) | Varies, often pay back 10-100% depending on income | Regular income above means test | |
| 5-30 years | Neutral (small initial dip, then positive) | 40-60% on interest vs credit cards | Homeowners with 20%+ equity | |
| 5 years max for loans | None (doesn't appear on credit) | Varies based on retirement impact | Substantial 401(k) balance | |
👨👩👧👦Family Loan | Negotiable | None | 100% of interest costs | Have willing family/friends |
Ready to Start Your Debt-Free Journey?
Get personalized recommendations based on your unique situation